| 2 May 2005, Reviewed
October 16, 2007
Weekly payment plans provide
no benefit to borrowers except the convenience to borrowers who are
paid weekly of paying their mortgage weekly, for whatever that is
worth.
"I have been following your advice by
increasing my monthly payment by 1/12. My lender has suggested that I instead
switch to a weekly payment plan, for which they charge $1 per payment. Would
this plan result in my paying off my loan sooner?"
No, because weekly payment plans do not
involve any additional payments. Your monthly payment is multiplied by 12 and
divided by 52 to get the weekly payment, so you make the equivalent of 12
monthly payments a year. When you increase the monthly payment by 1/12, you make
the equivalent of 13 payments a year.
You can make the two schemes comparable by
increasing the weekly payment by 1/12 as well. Then you would make the
equivalent of one extra monthly payment a year in both schemes. If you did that,
you would pay off a little sooner using the weekly payment scheme, provided the
weekly payments are applied weekly – meaning that the balance is reduced every
week. Ask the lender whether weekly payments are applied weekly, or whether they
are held until month-end.
"I was told that the weekly payments are held
in a special account, and on the first of every month a withdrawal is applied to
the mortgage payment."
That means that there is no interest saving to you in making weekly
payments. And since the $1 payment fee is added to the balance, your loan will
pay off less quickly under the weekly payment plan than under the monthly
payment plan you are using now.
If the lender applies weekly payments to the balance monthly, the only
possible benefit is to borrowers who are paid weekly. They may value the
convenience and budgetary discipline imposed by having to pay their mortgage
weekly. There is no other benefit.
Copyright Jack Guttentag 2007
|