March 8, 1999, Revised December 2, 2006, July 28, 2008
Mortgage repayment requirements are generally quite inflexible. You
cannot skip a payment and get back on track without making up the lost
payment.
"I wasn't able to make my April mortgage payment last year, the first
time in two years that happened, and I have made every payment on time
since then. But my lender sends me late charge notices every month since
that happened. And when I applied recently for a credit card, I was told
that I was a high-risk customer because of my mortgage payment
delinquencies. I only skipped one payment, so what is going on? "
Your loan contract does not give you the right to skip a payment. The
payment you skipped made you delinquent, and you have stayed delinquent
ever since.
Under the accounting rules used for amortized mortgages, lenders always
credit a payment against the earliest unpaid obligation. When you made
your payment last May, you received credit for April, which meant that
your May payment was late. When you made your payment in June, it was
applied to May, leaving the June payment delinquent, and so on. The
consequence is that a borrower who skips a payment but pays regularly
thereafter stays delinquent (and accumulates late fees) until the
skipped payment is made good.
The advantage of this method of accounting to the borrower is that a
delinquent payment is applied to both interest and principal just as it
would have been if paid on time, despite the fact that some interest due
has not been paid. For example, if your payment is $1,200 and interest
due in April was $900, $300 of the payment made in May is used to reduce
principal, even though another $900 of interest is due at that time. And
this means that as soon as you become current by making a double
payment, you are back on the amortization track -- the loan will pay off
on schedule.
The disadvantage is the rigidity, which can be devastating for someone
on a tight budget. The system has not been very innovative in developing
flexible payment plans. Accounting rules are man-made and there are
several other plausible ways to deal with late payments. One way is to
allow the borrower to skip a certain number of payments, say one per
year, and add the unpaid interest for that month to the principal. This
pre-authorized skipped payment would not be recorded as a delinquency
and would provide a nice safety valve for consumers. However, skipped
payments that added to the loan balance would result in the loan no
longer paying off on schedule. I have never seen an instrument of this
sort.
A way to provide the same type of safety valve to borrowers without
significantly affecting the pay off schedule is to increase the payment
by a factor of 13/12. In the example, the borrower would pay $1300
instead of $1200 but could skip the payment in December to finance
Christmas presents, or in June to take a trip. As far as I know, no
lender has ever offered this option, either. See
How Would a Truly Flexible Mortgage Plan Work?