Is Portability a Useful Option?
October 6, 2003, Updated June 17, 2009

"I have heard that you can now get a mortgage that can be moved from one property to another. That sounds like it would save me a lot of money because my company moves me every 3 or 4 years. Can you provide details?"

A portable mortgage is one that can be moved from one home to another. Instead of repaying your mortgage when you move and taking out a new one on the new home, you transfer the old mortgage to the new property.

Portable mortgages were a long time coming, they became available in 2003 when this article was first published from only one lender: E*TRADE Mortgage. E*TRADE offered the portability option on 30-year fixed-rate mortgages only, at an interest rate 3/8% higher than the rate on the identical mortgage without the option. To be eligible, borrowers had to purchase single-family homes as their permanent residence, they had to have squeaky-clean credit, and they had to provide full documentation.

There are two major benefits of a portable mortgage to the borrower. One is that it avoids the costs of taking out a new mortgage. On the E*Trade version, this cost saving must be set against the cost of paying 3/8% more in rate, which rises the longer the period between the first purchase and the second. I have done some comparisons, on the basis of which the break-even period comes out to roughly 4 years on a $150,000 loan. If you expect that you won't be buying your next house within 4 years, the cost saving on the future mortgage won't cover the cost penalty imposed by the 3/8% rate premium. The period is a little shorter on a larger loan, longer on a smaller loan.

But the portable mortgage has another benefit of considerable value. It allows you to avoid any rise in market interest rates that occurs between the time you purchase one house and the time you purchase the next one.

During my lifetime, I have seen mortgage rates as low as 4% and as high as 18%. When rates are at 6%, there is clearly much greater potential for rise than for decline. If rates increase, the portable mortgage protects you, and if they decrease, you can get the benefit by refinancing. There is no prepayment penalty.

Borrowers who confidently expect to move within 5 or 6 years and fear that a major spike in rates could seriously crimp their plans may find the 3/8% rate increment a reasonable insurance premium. It is less valuable for borrowers who expect to move every 3 years, since the transfer option can only be used once.

Portability is also less valuable for borrowers who expect to trade down when they move. Since they will need a smaller mortgage at that point, the rate protection is not worth as much. However, E*TRADE will recalculate their payment if the new mortgage is more than $10,000 smaller than the old one.

Borrowers who trade up cannot increase the original loan. E*TRADE will give them a second mortgage at the market rate on first mortgages at that time, but the sum of first and second mortgages cannot exceed 80% of property value. The borrower will have to pay settlement costs on the second - the same costs that a new borrower would have to pay at that time. Borrowers trading up could well find that they would do better getting a second mortgage from another lender.

Borrowers with the excellent credit needed to qualify for a portable mortgage should be confident that they can maintain that record. Borrowers in bankruptcy or behind in their payments cannot exercise the transfer option. In such a situation, they would have paid the 3/8% rate increment for nothing.

Unfortunately, E*Trade Mortgage folded during the recent financial crisis, and the portable mortgage is no longer available.
Sign up to Receive New Articles
Print